Really enjoyed the primer, super helpful to a mind-bogglingly complex topic. Wondering your thoughts on how IHL can adapt to address the necessary demarcation challenges between combatants and non-combatants, and help ensure civilians remain protected: thinking of civilians reporting Russian advances in Ukraine, for example.
Also, interested to hear more thoughts around 'on the loop.' You've pointed out the difficulty of answering these tough questions, but wondering whether MHC matters less when it comes to ISR (specifically, target acquisition)? Morally, I'd say MHC is still essential when identifying targets, but not as essential as the actual deployment of lethality? Sort of a chicken before the egg issue: is it less of a contravention if an operator is simply on the loop earlier up the kill chain? At what level in the kill chain does MHC become absolutely necessary? Just food for thought!
ISR feeds the targeting cycle. So I'm less concerned with that as capability and more with how the human, machine, or human-machine team (HMT) exercises its duty of distinction in identifying someone, or something, against whom/which force can legally be used.
Perhaps the better question is what role is that human playing in or on the loop? Are they set up for success such that any control they exert is meaningful? Better yet, and I intend to explore this further, will they even care enough to exert control they start to "trust" a system?
Your final question is THE question! Lemme know when you figure it out 😉
Really enjoyed the primer, super helpful to a mind-bogglingly complex topic. Wondering your thoughts on how IHL can adapt to address the necessary demarcation challenges between combatants and non-combatants, and help ensure civilians remain protected: thinking of civilians reporting Russian advances in Ukraine, for example.
Also, interested to hear more thoughts around 'on the loop.' You've pointed out the difficulty of answering these tough questions, but wondering whether MHC matters less when it comes to ISR (specifically, target acquisition)? Morally, I'd say MHC is still essential when identifying targets, but not as essential as the actual deployment of lethality? Sort of a chicken before the egg issue: is it less of a contravention if an operator is simply on the loop earlier up the kill chain? At what level in the kill chain does MHC become absolutely necessary? Just food for thought!
Looking forward to the next article.
You're asking the right questions!
ISR feeds the targeting cycle. So I'm less concerned with that as capability and more with how the human, machine, or human-machine team (HMT) exercises its duty of distinction in identifying someone, or something, against whom/which force can legally be used.
Perhaps the better question is what role is that human playing in or on the loop? Are they set up for success such that any control they exert is meaningful? Better yet, and I intend to explore this further, will they even care enough to exert control they start to "trust" a system?
Your final question is THE question! Lemme know when you figure it out 😉