Welcome
I’ve spent the bulk of my professional career grappling with one of the most existential questions of our time: how do we maintain the necessary degree humanity in warfare as we simultaneously race to remove the human?
I studied this as lawyer, worked on it as a legal officer in the Canadian Armed Forces, and am now watching, in real time, as companies around the world seek to build the tech stack that will enable lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS).
To state the obvious, this is an incredibly complicated issue that implicates almost all aspects of society, including law, ethics, culture, technology, engineering, and geopolitics. It is further strained by the fact that the technologies necessary to operationalize what was previously a dark though experiment – artificial intelligence and robotics – are rapidly maturing at a time when the world is more fractured than ever. The deteriorating international security environment is creating pressures, both real and imagined, impelling governments and industry to develop and field these technologies for fear of being left behind and finding themselves at an operational disadvantage.
Make no mistake, LAWS are coming; it’s when, not if. And, if we’re being honest, they’ll probably arrive sooner than we expect, meaning that we have a small window within which we can create the systems, processes, and safeguards necessary to create and field new weapons systems that confer real operational advantage, but also reflect and respect the laws and norms that we have collectively created to make war less terrible.
And so, rather than lie in bed at night rolling these issues around in my brain, or worse, continuing to bore my wife, I have started Means or Methods. I will use this as a place to work through the myriad questions surrounding LAWS, hopefully providing an answer or two along the way.
Let’s not bury the lede either. It is my broad contention that weapons reviews / Article 36 reviews are the overlooked venue within which implicated stakeholders must collaborate if LAWS are to be fielded in accordance with national laws and values. This concept will pervade this page, and I will return to it as consistently as possible in the hopes of teasing out useful ideas.
What this is, and what this isn’t
International and domestic law will also no doubt factor heavily in these discussions, but this is not going to be a series of law review style articles; there are plenty of other places for that. Besides, as I will establish, law is just one facet of this debate – important to be sure, but by no means dispositive.
What we will see is that developing and using LAWS in accordance with our values will be a multi-stakeholder, multi-disciplinary effort wherein societies must ask and answer a series of questions that, at the risk of sounding grandiose, will force them to define their own humanity in the age of machines.



“Law is just one facet of this debate” highlights a central issue in the discussion. The LAWS debate is highly-technical and not accessible.
I want to know what the deal is with the CIWS. You know? Does it get to be automated because it is well engineered, because it operates at sea with limited risk of collateral damage, because it is protecting something vitally important to protect…